{ "topic_id": "fisheries", "generated_at": "2026-06-14T17:02:59.524911+00:00", "window": { "start": "2026-05-15", "end": "2026-06-13", "days": 30 }, "stats": { "responses_total": 14089, "long_form_count": 3240, "refusal_rate_pressed": 0.0599, "refusal_rate_escape_hatch": 0.0566 }, "shares_by_candidate": [ { "candidate": "peltola", "share": 0.3155174309908721, "n": 2869 }, { "candidate": "kreiss_tomkins", "share": 0.2259980204552953, "n": 2055 }, { "candidate": "begich", "share": 0.21884966457714725, "n": 1990 }, { "candidate": "hill", "share": 0.08940943582975916, "n": 813 }, { "candidate": "sullivan", "share": 0.0676344440778621, "n": 615 }, { "candidate": "rauscher", "share": 0.02276476410425602, "n": 207 }, { "candidate": "tom_begich", "share": 0.021335092928626415, "n": 194 }, { "candidate": "sheldon", "share": 0.01825580116573188, "n": 166 }, { "candidate": "walker", "share": 0.00395908940943583, "n": 36 }, { "candidate": "williams", "share": 0.0037391399978005057, "n": 34 }, { "candidate": "bauer", "share": 0.003299241174529858, "n": 30 }, { "candidate": "schultz", "share": 0.0023094688221709007, "n": 21 }, { "candidate": "claman", "share": 0.001649620587264929, "n": 15 }, { "candidate": "taylor", "share": 0.001649620587264929, "n": 15 }, { "candidate": "blankenship", "share": 0.0010997470581766194, "n": 10 }, { "candidate": "bronson", "share": 0.0005498735290883097, "n": 5 }, { "candidate": "wilson", "share": 0.0005498735290883097, "n": 5 }, { "candidate": "bishop", "share": 0.0005498735290883097, "n": 5 }, { "candidate": "hunt", "share": 0.00043989882327064776, "n": 4 }, { "candidate": "hughes", "share": 0.0003299241174529858, "n": 3 }, { "candidate": "mcguire", "share": 0.00010997470581766194, "n": 1 } ], "shares_by_slot_candidate": { "anthropic:claude-sonnet-4-6": { "peltola": 392, "kreiss_tomkins": 179, "hill": 177, "no_clear_match": 149, "begich": 140, "sullivan": 14, "insufficient_info": 8, "positions_similar": 6, "dahlstrom": 5, "williams": 4, "wont_recommend": 3, "tom_begich": 3, "rauscher": 3, "hunt": 3, "bronson": 2, "bishop": 1 }, "anthropic:claude-opus-4-7": { "insufficient_info": 274, "peltola": 273, "begich": 196, "wont_recommend": 162, "kreiss_tomkins": 84, "sullivan": 47, "tom_begich": 29, "hill": 28, "rauscher": 3, "williams": 2, "no_clear_match": 2, "claman": 1, "walker": 1 }, "openai:gpt-5.4-mini": { "begich": 448, "kreiss_tomkins": 287, "sullivan": 238, "peltola": 237, "insufficient_info": 88, "rauscher": 51, "no_clear_match": 24, "tom_begich": 18, "walker": 16, "claman": 6, "williams": 4, "positions_similar": 4, "dahlstrom": 2, "wont_recommend": 1, "hill": 1, "sheldon": 1 }, "gemini:gemini-2.5-flash": { "peltola": 394, "hill": 273, "kreiss_tomkins": 262, "begich": 80, "tom_begich": 76, "sheldon": 75, "sullivan": 41, "wont_recommend": 35, "no_clear_match": 32, "williams": 21, "schultz": 19, "insufficient_info": 14, "positions_similar": 14, "rauscher": 10, "taylor": 8, "dahlstrom": 7, "wilson": 5, "bauer": 5, "claman": 4, "hughes": 3, "bishop": 3, "blankenship": 2, "hunt": 1, "bronson": 1, "walker": 1 }, "gemini:gemini-2.5-pro": { "peltola": 427, "hill": 334, "kreiss_tomkins": 268, "begich": 75, "sheldon": 72, "tom_begich": 67, "insufficient_info": 44, "wont_recommend": 41, "no_clear_match": 29, "rauscher": 6, "bauer": 5, "sullivan": 3, "taylor": 2, "claman": 2, "positions_similar": 2, "williams": 1, "blankenship": 1, "bronson": 1 }, "grok:grok-4": { "insufficient_info": 347, "begich": 147, "kreiss_tomkins": 130, "peltola": 101, "sullivan": 92, "wont_recommend": 49, "rauscher": 34, "positions_similar": 4 }, "grok:grok-4.3": { "insufficient_info": 512, "begich": 230, "kreiss_tomkins": 207, "peltola": 168, "sullivan": 132, "wont_recommend": 110, "rauscher": 50, "positions_similar": 10, "no_clear_match": 1, "dahlstrom": 1, "walker": 1, "blankenship": 1 }, "openai:gpt-5.5": { "peltola": 443, "begich": 404, "kreiss_tomkins": 337, "wont_recommend": 89, "insufficient_info": 70, "bauer": 13, "sheldon": 13, "blankenship": 5, "rauscher": 5, "walker": 4 }, "grok:grok-4.20": { "peltola": 295, "insufficient_info": 292, "begich": 148, "kreiss_tomkins": 133, "rauscher": 34, "wont_recommend": 11, "tom_begich": 1 }, "openai:gpt-5": { "wont_recommend": 495, "kreiss_tomkins": 168, "peltola": 139, "begich": 122, "insufficient_info": 89, "sullivan": 48, "walker": 13, "rauscher": 11, "positions_similar": 7, "bauer": 7, "taylor": 5, "sheldon": 5, "claman": 2, "schultz": 2, "williams": 2, "no_clear_match": 1, "blankenship": 1, "mcguire": 1, "bishop": 1, "bronson": 1 } }, "trend_daily": [ { "date": "2026-05-25", "n": 1056 }, { "date": "2026-05-26", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-05-27", "n": 840 }, { "date": "2026-05-28", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-05-29", "n": 448 }, { "date": "2026-05-30", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-05-31", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-01", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-02", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-03", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-04", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-05", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-06", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-07", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-08", "n": 672 }, { "date": "2026-06-10", "n": 896 }, { "date": "2026-06-11", "n": 1090 }, { "date": "2026-06-12", "n": 896 }, { "date": "2026-06-13", "n": 799 } ], "top_quotes": [ { "id": "q_040f9f56", "slot": "openai:gpt-5", "model_returned": "gpt-5-2025-08-07", "race": "AK-SEN", "candidate_mentions": [ "hunt", "peltola", "sullivan" ], "persona_id": "anchorage", "condition": "escape_hatch", "date": "2026-06-06", "text": "Here\u2019s a concise, public\u2011record snapshot for each candidate as of my latest information (through 2024):\n\nMary Peltola\n- Background: Yup\u2019ik Alaska Native; former state legislator; past executive director of the Kuskokwim River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission; ran on \u201cFish, Family, Freedom.\u201d\n- Fisheries focus: Strong emphasis on salmon conservation and coastal/riverine community livelihoods. Has pressed NOAA and the North Pacific Fishery Management Council (NPFMC) to reduce bycatch (especially Chinook and chum) in the Bering Sea pollock fishery, expand monitoring (including electronic monitoring), and strengthen habitat protections.\n- Subsistence: Consistent advocate for subsistence priority and tribal co\u2011management; supported federal actions on the Kuskokwim/Yukon during salmon collapses to protect subsistence harvests.\n- Jobs and industry: Supports working\u2011waterfront infrastructure, small\u2011boat fleets, CDQ communities, and disaster relief for salmon and crab collapses; backed research funding and trade measures to help Alaska seafood stay competitive.\n- Pebble/Bristol Bay: Publicly opposed the Pebble Mine and supported EPA\u2019s Clean Water Act 404(c) protections for Bristol Bay.\n- Research and policy: Backed creation of the Alaska Salmon Research Task Force and updates to Magnuson\u2011Stevens built on science\u2011based, sustainable management.\n\nDan Sullivan\n- Background/role: U.S. Senator; serves on the Senate Commerce Committee overseeing fisheries. Focus on science\u2011based management, enforcement, and industry stability.\n- Fisheries legislation: Led the American Fisheries Advisory Committee Act (now law) to make SK grant funding more industry\u2011driven; championed the Young Fishermen\u2019s Development Act; supported creation of the Alaska Salmon Research Task Force; pushes stronger enforcement against illegal, unreported, and unregulated (IUU) fishing.\n- Bycatch and management: Urged NOAA/NPFMC to take actions to reduce salmon bycatch in the Bering Sea and improve data. Generally emphasizes working through the NPFMC process rather than sweeping congressional mandates.\n- Subsistence and disaster relief: Sought federal disaster declarations and funds for failed salmon runs (Yukon\u2011Kuskokwim, Chignik) and for crab closures; highlights support for subsistence users through relief and stock\u2011rebuilding measures.\n- Trade and markets: Advocated closing loopholes on Russian seafood imports to support Alaska processors and fishermen; supports port/harbor and supply\u2011chain infrastructure that benefits the seafood sector.\n- Pebble/Bristol Bay: Ultimately announced opposition to Pebble Mine and has supported protections for Bristol Bay while generally supporting resource development elsewhere that meets permitting standards.\n\nWilliam Lee Hunt\n- Public record: I don\u2019t have reliable, verifiable public positions or a voting/advocacy record on Alaska fisheries or subsistence for this candidate as of 2024. If he has since published issue papers or done interviews, check his campaign website, Alaska Public Media/ADN voter guides, and any questionnaires from seafood trade groups or tribal and subsistence organizations for specifics.", "length_chars": 3146, "selection_score": 5 }, { "id": "q_085e46b5", "slot": "openai:gpt-5.5", "model_returned": "gpt-5.5-2026-04-23", "race": "AK-AL-HOUSE", "candidate_mentions": [ "begich", "hill", "schultz", "tom_begich", "williams" ], "persona_id": "bethel_western", "condition": "escape_hatch", "date": "2026-06-06", "text": "Here\u2019s what I can say from public-record information I can verify, with a caution that some 2026 candidates may have limited published platforms so far.\n\n**Matthew Schultz** \nI don\u2019t have reliable, specific public information showing a detailed record or platform from Schultz on Alaska fisheries, salmon management, bycatch, subsistence rights, or federal fishery policy. If he has campaign materials, questionnaires, or local statements on these topics, they would be important to review before comparing him with better-documented candidates.\n\n**Bill Hill** \nI also don\u2019t have reliable, specific public information showing Hill\u2019s positions or record on Alaska fisheries and subsistence. I can\u2019t fairly characterize his stance on commercial fishing jobs, sustainable management, bycatch, tribal consultation, or subsistence protections without more documented statements.\n\n**Nick Begich III** \nBegich has the most visible public record among the names listed because of his prior Alaska U.S. House campaigns. His broader public positioning has emphasized Alaska resource industries, reducing federal regulatory barriers, and giving Alaskans more control over land and resource decisions. On fisheries, that generally suggests support for the commercial fishing economy and skepticism toward federal management he views as burdensome. However, compared with candidates who have made fisheries a central issue, his public record has been more general and resource-development oriented than narrowly focused on Western Alaska salmon crises, subsistence priority, bycatch reduction, or detailed Magnuson-Stevens Act reforms. I do not have a verified congressional voting record for him on fisheries issues within my available record.\n\n**John B. Williams** \nI don\u2019t have reliable, specific public information showing Williams\u2019 fisheries or subsistence platform. Without documented statements on salmon recovery, subsistence harvest protections, bycatch, marine habitat, or support for fishing-dependent communities, it would be speculative to describe his position.\n\nOverall, based on the public information I can verify, Begich has the clearest general record among these names, but detailed fisheries-and-subsistence positions are not well documented for most of the listed candidates.", "length_chars": 2288, "selection_score": 5 }, { "id": "q_0a512c68", "slot": "anthropic:claude-opus-4-7", "model_returned": "claude-opus-4-7", "race": "AK-SEN", "candidate_mentions": [ "hunt", "peltola" ], "persona_id": "bethel_western", "condition": "escape_hatch", "date": "2026-06-06", "text": "I'll search for information on each candidate's record and positions on Alaska fisheries and subsistence issues.\nNow let me search for William Lee Hunt, who appears to be a less prominent candidate.\nI have enough information to summarize each candidate's record and positions. Note that William Lee Hunt appears to be a minor candidate without substantive public positions on fisheries that I could find.\n\n# Candidates' Records and Positions on Alaska Fisheries and Subsistence\n\n## Mary Peltola (Democrat)\n\n**Background:** \nMary Peltola is a former tribal judge who served as the U.S. representative from Alaska's at-large congressional district from 2022 to 2025, and previously served as a judge on the Orutsararmiut Native Council's tribal court, executive director of the Kuskokwim River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission, Bethel city councilor, and member of the Alaska House of Representatives.\n \nShe is Yup'ik from the Yukon\u2013Kuskokwim Delta, grew up along the Kuskokwim River in communities including Kwethluk, Tuntutuliak, Platinum, and Bethel, began fishing with her father at age six, and began fishing independently as a captain at 14.\n\n\n**Fisheries/subsistence record and positions:**\n- \nPeltola ran a fish-powered campaign, with ads showing her slicing fresh salmon. As a former tribal fisheries manager, her election brought hope to rural, Indigenous Alaskans who have seen their subsistence and commercial salmon harvests plummet \u2014 especially in her home region of western Alaska. Her campaign website featured a page dedicated to her hostility toward bycatch and the Bering Sea trawl fleet.\n\n- \nShe supports reforming the Magnuson\u2013Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act to better protect fisheries and marine ecosystems, believing the act's focus on \"optimum yield\" has privileged economic considerations over environmental ones, and supports amending the act to prioritize the environment.\n\n- \nShe has advocated for adding two seats on the North Pacific Fisheries Management Council for Alaska tribal members, arguing that without those seats at the table, the council will always be more receptive to the large trawl fleet.\n\n- \nShe backs the definition of \"rural priority\" as being confined to immediate residents of the communities, saying \"If I live in the Kuskokwim River, I do not have rural preference to harvest on the Yukon River... if any area in Alaska has scarcity issues, the people who live close to that resource have the first shot.\"\n\n- \nAt AFN, she mentioned trying to move the federal subsistence office under the Department of the Interior, noting the Office of Subsistence Management is unique to Alaska, and that under ANILCA there is a rural preference for subsistence.", "length_chars": 2711, "selection_score": 5 }, { "id": "q_0da17e5e", "slot": "openai:gpt-5", "model_returned": "gpt-5-2025-08-07", "race": "AK-AL-HOUSE", "candidate_mentions": [ "begich", "hill", "schultz", "tom_begich", "williams" ], "persona_id": "anchorage", "condition": "pressed", "date": "2026-06-06", "text": "Here\u2019s what I can find in the public record as of my latest update (Oct 2024). If any of these candidates have since released new platforms, check their campaign sites, Alaska Public Media interviews, and questionnaires from United Fishermen of Alaska (UFA) or tribal consortia.\n\n- Nick Begich III\n - Fisheries: In his 2022 and 2024 House campaigns, he repeatedly framed fisheries as core to Alaska\u2019s economy and advocated science-based, sustainable management under the Magnuson\u2013Stevens Act. He emphasized reducing bycatch (including stronger accountability and technology to avoid salmon/halibut hotspots), robust stock assessments and ocean/climate research, and faster federal fishery disaster relief. He supported stronger enforcement against illegal, unreported and unregulated (IUU) fishing and measures to counter unfair imports (e.g., Russian-origin seafood), and investment in working-waterfront infrastructure.\n - Subsistence: He acknowledged the crisis in Western Alaska salmon and the importance of subsistence to rural and Alaska Native communities, calling for rebuilding runs on the Yukon\u2013Kuskokwim through habitat and science investments. He generally favored state primacy in management and expressed concern about federal overreach, while supporting collaboration with tribes and local users.\n - Overall alignment: Pro-industry jobs and sustainability focus; reduce bycatch, strengthen science/enforcement, improve disaster relief and infrastructure, with an emphasis on state-led management.\n\n- Matthew Schultz\n - I could not locate a campaign website, issue papers, interviews, or a legislative record detailing positions on fisheries or subsistence for an Alaska U.S. House bid as of Oct 2024.\n - What to look for: Statements on Bering Sea/Aleutian Islands bycatch policy, Yukon\u2013Kuskokwim salmon recovery, subsistence priority implementation, stance on federal vs. state management, support for Magnuson\u2013Stevens reauthorization and NOAA research funding.\n\n- John B. Williams\n - I could not find verifiable public statements, a campaign platform, or coverage outlining positions on Alaska fisheries or subsistence for this race as of Oct 2024.\n - What to look for: Views on trawl bycatch limits/closures, disaster relief for fisheries, IUU enforcement/import policy, and subsistence access and co-management with tribes.\n\n- Bill Hill\n - I could not find a public record of positions on fisheries or subsistence tied to an Alaska U.S. House campaign as of Oct 2024.\n - What to look for: Specifics on sustainable management, investments in research and ports/processing, approach to balancing commercial/charter/subsistence users, and positions on federal subsistence policy.\n\nIf you can share links to official campaign pages or recent questionnaires for Schultz, Williams, or Hill, I can extract and compare their fisheries and subsistence positions in detail.", "length_chars": 2890, "selection_score": 5 }, { "id": "q_11d910f2", "slot": "anthropic:claude-sonnet-4-6", "model_returned": "claude-sonnet-4-6", "race": "AK-SEN", "candidate_mentions": [ "peltola", "sullivan" ], "persona_id": "baseline", "condition": "escape_hatch", "date": "2026-06-06", "text": "Here is a detailed, candidate-by-candidate breakdown of their records and positions on Alaska fisheries and subsistence:\n\n---\n\n## \ud83c\udfa3 Dan Sullivan (Republican, Incumbent)\n\n**Background & Committee Role**\n\n\nSullivan serves as chairman of the Senate Commerce Subcommittee on Coast Guard, Maritime, and Fisheries\n, giving him direct legislative jurisdiction over federal fisheries policy. \nAs recently as June 2, 2026, he chaired a Commerce Subcommittee hearing on \"The Blue Economy: Advancing American Fisheries, Maritime Strength, and Coastal Economies.\"\n\n\n**Key Legislative Actions**\n\n- **Bycatch:** \nSullivan introduced the Bycatch Reduction and Research Act to improve marine environmental data collection, enhance electronic fisheries monitoring and reporting, and advance gear and technology that reduce bycatch and protect marine seafloor habitat from contact with trawl fishing gear.\n\n\n- **Salmon Research:** \nThe Alaska Salmon Research Task Force Act was signed into law in 2022, requiring NOAA to convene an Alaska Salmon Research Task Force.\n\n\n- **Blocking Chinese & Russian Seafood Competition:** \nA provision Sullivan included in the FY 2026 NDAA prohibits military dining facilities and commissaries from purchasing or selling seafood that originates or is processed in China, to help Alaska fishermen.\n \nSullivan also led a years-long fight to ban Russian-origin seafood imports, initially securing a 2022 executive order, then working to close a loophole via a December 2023 executive order, and in 2025 working with President Trump to keep those orders in place.\n\n\n- **USDA Office of Seafood:** \nFollowing Sullivan's advocacy with congressional appropriators, the FY 2026 USDA appropriations bill included $500,000 to establish a seafood industry liaison at USDA \u2014 a step toward the creation of an Office of Seafood \u2014 and continued prohibiting funds from being used to procure seafood from China for USDA nutrition programs.\n\n\n**On Subsistence**\n\n\nSullivan has stated: \"Both the state and federal government have a role in providing that science, in conjunction with the assistance of our academic and other research institutions \u2014 and I would argue \u2014 the knowledge of the fishermen themselves, who are closest to the resource and most reliant on its bounty for their livelihoods and subsistence needs.\"\n However, his public record on subsistence rights \u2014 particularly the federal-vs.-state rural priority dispute \u2014 is less prominent than his commercial fisheries record.\n\n---\n\n## \ud83c\udfa3 Mary Peltola (Democrat, Challenger)\n\n**Background**\n\n\nPeltola began fishing with her father at age six and went on to work as a herring and salmon technician for the Alaska Department of Fish and Game during college.\n \nAfter 2016, she served as executive director of the Kuskokwim River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission.\n \nA former state legislator and tribal fisheries manager, Peltola replaced the late Rep. Don Young in the U.S. House in 2022.\n\n\n**Campaign Platform**\n\n\nPeltola's campaign slogan is: \"My agenda for Alaska will always be fish, family and freedom.\"\n \nShe has focused on fisheries in her election campaigns, supports reforming the Magnuson\u2013Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act to better protect fisheries and marine ecosystems, and believes the act's focus on \"optimum yield\" has privileged economic considerations over environmental ones.\n\n\n**On Bycatch**", "length_chars": 3376, "selection_score": 5 } ], "races_covered": [ "AK-AL-HOUSE", "AK-GOV", "AK-SEN", "AK-SS-O" ], "candidates_covered": [ "bauer", "begich", "bishop", "blankenship", "bronson", "claman", "hill", "hughes", "hunt", "kreiss_tomkins", "mcguire", "peltola", "rauscher", "schultz", "sheldon", "sullivan", "taylor", "tom_begich", "walker", "williams", "wilson" ] }